Now,

<<[if what is] prepared

<<for a person

<<is not

<<considered

<<prepared

<<for dogs —

<<as we learned:

<<one may cut

<<gourds

<<before

<<the animal,

<<and a carcass

<<before

<<the dogs.

<<Rabbi Yehuda

<<says:

<<if

<<it was not

<<a carcass

<<from Shabbos eve,

<<it is prohibited,

<<because

<<it is not

<<of what is prepared —

<<[can what is] prepared

<<for dogs

<<be

<<prepared

<<for a person?!

He said to him:

<<yes;

<<prepared

<<for a person

<<is not

<<considered

<<prepared

<<for dogs,

<<for what

<<is fit

<<for a person

<<he does not

<<throw

<<it

<<to dogs;

<<prepared

<<for dogs

<<is

<<prepared

<<for a person,

<<for the mind

<<of a person

<<is on anything

<<that is fit for him.

It is taught

<<in accordance with

<<Rav;

<<it is taught

<<in accordance with

<<Shmuel —

<<and some say

<<Rabbi Yochanan.

It is taught

<<in accordance with

<<Rav:

<<a calf

<<that was born

<<on Yom Tov

<<is permitted;

<<a chick

<<that hatched

<<on Yom Tov

<<is prohibited.

<<And what

<<difference is there

<<between

<<this

<<and that?

<<This one

<<is prepared

<<by virtue of

<<its mother

<<through slaughter,

<<and this one

<<is not

<<prepared

<<by virtue of

<<its mother.

It is taught

<<in accordance with

<<Shmuel —

<<and some say

<<Rabbi Yochanan:

<<a calf

<<that was born

<<on Yom Tov

<<is permitted,

<<and a chick

<<that hatched

<<on Yom Tov

<<is permitted.

<<What is the reason?

<<This one

<<is prepared

<<by virtue of

<<its mother,

<<and this one

<<permits

<<itself

<<through slaughter.

The Rabbis taught:

<<a chick

<<that hatched

<<on Yom Tov

<<is prohibited.

<<Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov

<<says:

<<even

<<on a weekday

<<it is prohibited,

<<because

<<have not

<<opened

<<its eyes.

In accordance with whom

<<goes

<<this

<<that is taught:

<<‘including all

<<the creeping things

<<that creep

<<on the earth’ —

<<to include

<<chicks

<<that have not

<<opened

<<their eyes?

<<In accordance with whom?

<<Like Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov.

Rav Huna said in the name of Rav:

<<an egg —

<<with

<<its emergence

<<it is completed.

<<What is

<<‘with

<<its emergence

<<it is completed’?

<<If you say

<<with

<<its emergence

<<it is completed

<<and is permitted

<<to eat it

<<with milk,

<<but

<<in the innards of

<<its mother

<<it is prohibited

<<to eat it

<<with milk —

<<but it is taught:

<<one who slaughters

<<a hen

<<and found

<<in it

<<eggs

<<fully formed —

<<they are permitted

<<to eat them

<<with milk!

Rather:

<<with

<<its emergence

<<it is completed

<<and is permitted

<<to eat it

<<on Yom Tov;

<<but

<<in the innards of

<<its mother

<<it is prohibited

<<to eat it

<<on Yom Tov —

<<but it is taught:

<<one who slaughters

<<a hen

<<and found

<<in it

<<eggs

<<fully formed —

<<they are permitted

<<to eat them

<<on Yom Tov!

And if you say:

<<it teaches us

<<in the Baraisa

<<what

<<was not

<<taught to us

<<in the Mishnah —

<<but this

<<too

<<we learned:

<<an egg

<<that was laid

<<on Yom Tov —

<<Beis Shammai

<<say:

<<it may be eaten;

<<and Beis Hillel

<<say:

<<it may not

<<be eaten.

<<And until here

<<do not

<<disagree

<<Beis Shammai

<<and Beis Hillel

<<except

<<about one that was laid;

<<but

<<in the innards of

<<their mother,

<<all agree

<<they are permitted.

And if you say

<<Beis Hillel

<<even

<<in the innards of

<<their mother

<<too

<<prohibit,

<<and this

<<that it teaches

<<‘was laid’ is

<<to inform you of

<<the strength of

<<Beis Shammai,

<<that even

<<one that was laid

<<too

<<they permit —

<<but

<<this

<<that is taught:

<<one who slaughters

<<a hen

<<and found

<<in it

<<eggs

<<fully formed —

<<they are permitted

<<to eat them

<<on Yom Tov —

<<whose view is it?

<<Not

<<Beis Shammai

<<and not

<<Beis Hillel!

Rather:

<<with

<<its emergence

<<it is completed

<<and can raise

<<chicks;

<<in the innards of

<<its mother

<<it does not

<<raise

<<chicks.

<<What is the practical difference?

<<For buying

<<and selling,

<<like

<<that one

<<who said

<<to them:

<<eggs